Questions to ask a property management company
The first question almost every co-op and condo board asks a managing agent is "how many units do you manage?" It is a reasonable thing to want to know and it is the weakest question on the list, because the answer tells you about the firm's size and almost nothing about what your building will get.
Nine better questions are below, each with what a good answer sounds like and what a weak one sounds like. We have answered them for ourselves at the bottom, so you can use the page on us as easily as on anyone else.
Get this wrong and you will find out in month four, which in a co-op usually means an inspection cycle nobody tracked, a set of books nobody can read, or a board that has to call the office to learn what is in its own bank account.
Why the unit count is the wrong opener
A firm with 10,000 units may have 40 people and give you a junior manager with 25 buildings. Somewhere with 2,000 units may give you the principal. The number on its own does not separate those two outcomes, and boards tend to ask it first and get to the questions that matter last, if at all.
Here is the honest version from our side of the table: we manage about 2,000 units across 35 buildings with eight full-time staff. If unit count decided this, we would lose to firms that are worse for your building. So we would rather you ask the next nine.
1. Which of your other buildings look like mine?
You want buildings of your type, your size and your era, in your borough. A co-op is a different job from a rental building. A 1920s elevator building with a facade cycle is a different job from a 1990s walk-up.
A good answer names the type, the size range and the neighborhoods without naming clients. A weak answer is a total unit count again.
2. How many people work here, and who will be on my building?
Ask for the full-time head count and the name of the person who will actually answer your emails. Then ask how many buildings that person carries.
A firm that cannot tell you the second number has not thought about it, which means nobody is watching whether your manager is overloaded.
3. What is your process when a deadline is six months out?
This separates firms more sharply than anything else on the list. New York City runs several inspection cycles at once, each on its own clock:
| The law | What it covers | The clock |
|---|---|---|
| Local Law 11 | Facade inspection and repair | Every 5 years, by block number |
| Local Law 97 | Building carbon limits | Phased in, with fines for going over |
| Local Law 152 | Gas piping inspection | Every 4 years, by community district |
| Local Law 126 | Parking structure assessment | Every 6 years, by borough |
Ask to see a compliance calendar for a building they already manage, with the dates blanked out if they prefer. A firm that plans a year ahead will have one on screen in about ten seconds. One that works off violation notices will describe a process instead of showing you a document.
4. What can our board see without asking you?
The right answer is a portal with monthly reports the board signs into. The wrong answer is that they will send you whatever you ask for, which sounds accommodating and means every question costs you an email and a wait.
Ask the same thing about residents. If shareholders can see their own ledger and payment history themselves, that is a large share of the office's phone calls gone, and it is the clearest sign a firm has actually invested in its systems rather than talked about it.
5. What software do you run, and was it built for co-ops?
A cooperative has an underlying lease. Software written for rental buildings has nowhere to put one, so it lives in a cabinet and in somebody's memory.
Ask the name of the system and ask whether it was built for New York City cooperatives. If the answer is a general accounting package, that is not disqualifying, but you should know you are hiring a firm that will be working around its own tools.
6. What does the fee cover, and what gets billed on top?
Get the base fee, then get the list of everything billed separately: closings, sublets, alteration reviews, late-night callouts, special projects. The second list is where two quotes that looked the same stop being the same.
Ask for the minimum too. Ours is $2,000 a month, and on a building under about 40 units that is a real number per apartment. A firm that will not state a floor is usually about to quote you one anyway.
7. Who holds the license?
In New York, collecting rent or maintenance for someone else for a fee is the legal definition of acting as a real estate broker. New York Real Property Law section 440 covers anyone who "collects or offers or attempts to collect rent for the use of real estate" for another, for a fee.
So ask who at the firm holds the broker's license and ask for the number. It takes a minute to check and most boards never do it.
8. What will you find in our building in the first 90 days?
A good answer is a plan: pull the filing history, pull the open violations, read the books, and see whether the records and the books agree.
A firm that promises a smooth transition and nothing else is telling you it does not expect to look. On a building that has been poorly managed, the first 90 days is where the surprises are, and you want them found then rather than in year three.
9. What happens when something breaks at 11pm?
Ask who picks up, ask what the escalation looks like, and ask what the board hears the next morning. Then ask the same question about a Saturday in August.
Our own answers
| The question | Our answer |
|---|---|
| Buildings like mine | 27 co-ops, 5 condos and 3 rental buildings, 35 in all, in Manhattan, Queens and Brooklyn |
| Head count | 8 full time. Adam Kapner, the principal, is on your building |
| Deadlines | Compliance calendar planned a year ahead, and the board sees it |
| What the board sees | Board portal with monthly reports, signed into directly |
| What residents see | Their own ledger, balance and payment history |
| Software | Built for New York City cooperatives, tracks underlying leases |
| Minimum fee | $2,000 a month |
| License | Adam Kapner holds a New York real estate broker's license |
| Founded | 2013 |
Where we are the wrong answer
Under about 40 units, our minimum fee usually makes a smaller firm the better deal for your shareholders, and we will say so in the first meeting.
If your building's main problem is leasing and turnover rather than governance and compliance, a firm built around rentals will serve you better. Almost everything we do is built around boards.
And if your board wants a manager who will tell you what you want to hear about a facade cycle, that is not going to be us.
What to do with the answers
Ask all nine of the same three firms and write the answers in one column each. The pattern shows up fast, and it is usually not the firm with the biggest unit count.
If you want ours in person, tell us about your building or schedule a meeting. If you are mostly here to prepare for interviews with other firms, that is a fine use of this page.
Frequently asked questions
How many property management companies should a board interview?
Three is the number most boards land on. It is enough to see a pattern in the answers and few enough that you can run the same list of questions through each one and compare them properly.
Is a bigger property management company better?
Not by itself. Size buys depth of staff and sometimes better purchasing, and it also means your building is a smaller share of the firm's revenue and your manager carries more doors. Ask how many buildings your specific manager handles, which is the number that actually predicts your experience.
What should a NYC managing agent cost?
Fees are usually quoted monthly and scale with unit count and how much work the building generates, with extras billed separately. Our own floor is $2,000 a month. Ask every firm for the base fee and the list of what sits outside it, because that second list is where comparable quotes stop being comparable.
Can we change managing agents mid-year?
Yes, subject to the notice period in your management agreement, which is commonly 30 to 90 days. Read your current agreement before you start interviewing, because the notice terms shape your timeline more than anything a new firm will tell you.
What is the single most useful question on this list?
Number 3. Ask to see a compliance calendar for a building they already manage. A firm that plans deadlines a year out can show you one immediately, and one that does not will talk about process instead.