Long Island property management
Vanderbilt NYC APT manages two properties on Long Island and is deliberately looking for more. The rest of our work, 35 buildings and about 2,000 units, is in Manhattan, Queens and Brooklyn, almost all of it cooperative.
Long Island is a different job, and that is the appeal rather than a drawback. Homeowners associations and townhouse communities out here carry less regulation and take less labor to run than a prewar elevator co-op in Manhattan. Boards feel that in two places: the compliance budget and the staffing line.
What changes once you cross the city line
Local Law 11, Local Law 97, Local Law 152 and Local Law 126 are New York City laws, enforced by the New York City Department of Buildings, and they apply to buildings in the five boroughs. A community in Nassau or Suffolk County is not in any of those cycles.
That removes the single largest source of unplanned cost from a city board's year. No five-year facade cycle keyed to a block number. No community district gas deadline. No borough parking window with a 90-day repair clock behind it.
What replaces it is local. Town and village codes, your own declaration and bylaws, and whatever your community's governing documents require of the board. The work is real, it is just smaller and more predictable, and the budget can be planned further out because of it.
Why we want more of this work
Two reasons, and both are honest self-interest rather than a pitch.
A townhouse community is less labor intensive per unit than a city building with a super, a doorman, a boiler room and four inspection cycles running at once. That is a better business for us.
And the discipline we built for city compliance transfers cleanly. A firm that plans a Manhattan facade cycle a year ahead does not find a Long Island reserve study or a roof replacement schedule difficult. The habits are the same and the pressure is lower.
What a Long Island board gets
The same systems our city boards use, which were built for a harder environment.
Board members sign into a portal and read the monthly reports themselves rather than waiting for a packet. Residents sign in to see their own ledger, balance and payment history, which is most of the reason people call a management office in the first place. Assessments, arrears, vendor contracts and the annual budget all live in the same place.
Our view is that the more a community runs through the portal, the fewer calls land on the office and the more the board can see without asking. Efficiency and transparency end up being the same project.
What changes when a self-managed community hires its first manager
Plenty of Long Island communities run themselves for years, and the ones with an engaged board and a quiet building are often right to. The handover, when it comes, is less about day to day work than about where information lives.
Four things move in the first few months.
The records come out of people's houses. Vendor contracts, insurance certificates, the declaration, the bylaws, minutes, the reserve study. In a self-managed community these are spread across three or four homes and a shared drive nobody has the password to. Getting them into one place is the first job and usually the slowest.
The money gets a separation of duties. One person collecting, recording and reconciling is normal in a self-managed community and is the arrangement every auditor flags. A manager in the middle means the person approving a payment is not the person making it.
Arrears stop being personal. Chasing a neighbor for common charges is the job nobody wants, and it is the reason self-managed communities carry higher arrears than managed ones. Handing it to a third party takes the relationship out of it.
The board stops being on call. Residents call the office rather than a board member at dinner. That one change is the reason most volunteers say yes to a second term.
The reserve question
The question we would put to any Long Island board, before anything about fees, is when the reserve study was last updated.
A reserve study is an engineer's view of what the community owns in common, how long each piece has left and what replacing it will cost. Roofs, roads, siding, the pool, the clubhouse. Boards that have one price their monthly charges against it. Boards that do not tend to price against last year's charges plus a little, which works right up until the roads need resurfacing.
The failure is slow and it is not dramatic. A community underfunds the reserve for a decade, nobody notices because nothing has broken, and then one capital item comes due and the board has to choose between a special assessment nobody budgeted for and a loan the community pays interest on. Both outcomes are the same decision made ten years earlier.
We would rather have that conversation in year one than in year ten, and it is usually the first thing we ask to see.
Being straight about our Long Island presence
Two properties is two properties. We are not going to tell you we are a Long Island firm.
What we are is a New York City management company with eight full-time staff, 35 buildings and a principal who takes board calls, expanding into a market we like. If you want a manager whose entire book is Nassau and Suffolk communities, those firms exist and you should talk to them. What we are offering is a city-grade reporting and compliance operation run on a community where the stakes are lower.
We would rather you knew that before the first meeting than after.
Who you deal with
Adam Kapner founded the company in 2013 and is the person on your community. John Cirella is second in command, with eight full-time staff behind them.
Adam holds a New York real estate broker's license. Under New York Real Property Law section 440, a person who collects rent or common charges for another, for a fee, is acting as a real estate broker. The statute is state law, so it applies on Long Island the same as it does in the city. Ask every firm you interview who holds the license.
Talk to us about your community
Tell us the number of homes, the town and what your board is finding hardest right now.
Tell us about your community or schedule a meeting.
Interviewing more than one firm? Take the questions to ask a property management company into all of them. Most of it applies out here, apart from the New York City compliance question.
Frequently asked questions
Do the NYC local laws apply to a Long Island community?
No. Local Law 11, 97, 152 and 126 are New York City laws enforced by the New York City Department of Buildings and they cover buildings in the five boroughs. A Nassau or Suffolk community answers to its town or village code and its own governing documents instead.
How many Long Island properties do you manage?
Two, and we want more. The bulk of the firm is in Manhattan, Queens and Brooklyn. We would rather tell you that than imply a larger local presence than we have.
Do you manage homeowners associations as well as townhouse communities?
Those are usually the same conversation out here. The board, the common charges, the reserve, the vendors and the annual meeting are the work, and our reporting is built around exactly that.
Is a city management company a strange choice for Long Island?
It depends on what your board wants. A city firm brings tighter reporting and compliance habits because the city environment demands them. A local firm brings relationships with local trades and more buildings nearby. Both are real advantages and the right answer is whichever your board is short of.
When should a self-managed community hire a management company?
The usual triggers are a long-serving volunteer stepping back, a capital project starting, or arrears getting high enough that somebody has to chase neighbors. A quiet community with an engaged board and no project running is often right to stay self-managed and keep the fee.
What should we ask for before hiring anyone out here?
The current reserve study, or an honest answer about why there is not one. Everything else on a management proposal is easier to compare once you know what the community owes itself over the next twenty years.
Does a Long Island manager need a New York license?
New York Real Property Law section 440 is state law, so collecting rent or common charges for another for a fee makes a firm a real estate broker anywhere in New York State, not only in the city. Ask for the license number wherever you are.